Methodology and madness: How Trump’s tweet subjects have evolved over time

  1. Presenting the Trump Watch (tick…tick…tick..)
  2. New Dataset – @realDonaldTrump Tweet corpus
  3. Just how oddball is @realdonaldtrump compared to other politicians?
  4. The anti-Trump shield: A defensive charity finder to help you put your money where his mouth is
  5. Breaking down the Women’s March: Even small-town marchers out-numbered the inauguration
  6. Trump cabinet bingo card generator
  7. Trump Watch historical: How has @realDonaldTrump’s use of Twitter evolved since Election Day?
  8. The tweet rate monitor: Is there any rhythm to Trump’s twitter blasts?
  9. Mapping the pep rally president
  10. Let’s play Trump Twitter bingo!
  11. The anti-Trump charity guide: What has Trump been effective at attacking in his first 9 months?
  12. Trump Watch retrospective: What did we learn in 2017?
  13. Fear and loathing of a very stable genius: What causes Trump’s rage tweets?
  14. Methodology and madness: How Trump’s tweet subjects have evolved over time
  15. Trump’s Twitter account charts a history of his presidency
  16. Trump’s tweet frequency is not dependent on his work schedule
  17. Trump’s Twitter pulpit is slowly losing its effectiveness
  18. How did President’s Trump language influence the El Paso shooter’s manifesto?

By: Patrick W. Zimmerman

We’ve spent quite a lot of time on the Twittering habits, patterns, activities, and vagaries of one Donald J. Trump.  However, looking at the whole dataset can sometimes hide important variations within a given variable (say, if el Presidente is obsessed with something for a month, totally forgot about it for the next two, then went nuts again).

So it begs the question: has anything changed since November 2016?

Let’s find out!  We’ll chop the Age of Donald into 2-month segments, large enough to give us a bit of a sample to work with (412 tweets, on average, totaling 8957 words).  Then, we’ll parse those to look for each of our 1000+ ngrams in each discrete 2 months segment and then aggregate them by subject. This lets us, say, see how his discussion of the Russia investigation has changed (to pull a totally random example, we swear).

In other words, what’s new, Donnie?

The question

Does Trump have favorite subjects that he likes to consistently tweet about, or do his topics fluctuate as he reacts to a changing political climate?

The short-short version

The quick answer is: both.  Trump has some subjects that he always likes to natter about more often than the average politician (his economic nationalism, the Media, for example).  But there are some that have definitely come up in response to the world around him (his opponents, the Deep State, his administration).

So while Trump’s overall tweet volume has steadily increased over time, it’s happening pretty steadily across all of the subjects mentioned, with some notable exceptions.

The results

When the Donald feels threatened, he tweets about his opponents a lot.

When the Donald takes a breath, he tweets about the media a lot.

One of these two things is a constant drumbeat, and one has varied a bit.

Mouseover for details.

It’s also interesting that Trump does not directly talk about the Russia investigation in as unusual a way as is usually portrayed (at least as measured by tf-idf compared to the body of congressional twitter accounts).  Why not?  Because other politicians also have picked up some of his terminology (witch hunt, etc).  He’s much more likely to say something in a wacko way about The Deep State, a concept that has caught on like crazy among the QAnon conspiracy-theorists of the world but which, for some reason, the legislative branch of that same state has been less quick to adopt.

There were also a number of categories whose frequency doesn’t seem to vary all that much. His white nationalism has increased a bit, but still is a relatively rare (though incredibly remarkable and dangerous) component of Trump’s twitter habit.  His shout-outs to his fawning fans in the Yes-Media and in the general electorate haven’t varied that much.  They’re weird, and very particular to Trump’s ego, but they seem to be much more a kind of cosmic background radiation to Trumplandia.

Mouseover for details.

Oh look, it’s not just you.  He is tweeting way more often than he used to.  Note that the last little dip only represents one of the two months in that segment (July 2018).  So no, he hasn’t suddenly stopped recently, either.

Also, once you normalize tweet volume to account for the twitter character limit doubling of November 17, 2017, then his tweet length is actually down a tick compared to his tweet volume since the expansion.  Though not a lot.

What next?

Well, it’s clear that he’s become increasingly anxious.  It’s pretty well established that Trump lashes out when cornered. He’s lashing out now, particularly at his opponents in the Democratic Party and the Deep State.

The million dollar questions are:

  1. Is there some breaking point, where he either snaps, crosses some line on Twitter that spurns action against him of a substantial nature, or where the platform loses its effectiveness?
  2. How will his spike in tweet volume and tweet aggressiveness affect the opinion of voters in November? And, if the composition of the Legislative branch changes, how does that affect the goalposts for #1?

My best guesses are: yes to 1, but only if 2 results in the Democrats taking the House.  Which is possible, maybe even likely, but far from a sure thing.

About The Author

Architeuthis Rex, a man of (little) wealth and (questionable) taste. Historian and anthropologist interested in identity, regionalism / nationalism, mass culture, and the social and political contexts in which they exist. Earned Ph.D. in social and cultural History with a concentration in anthropology from Carnegie Mellon University and then (mostly) fled academia to write things that more than 10 other people will actually read. Driven to pursue a doctorate to try and answer the question, "Why do they all hate each other?" — still working on it. Plays beer-league hockey, softball, and soccer. Professional toddler wrangler. Likes dogs, good booze, food, and horribly awesome kung-fu movies.

No Comments on "Methodology and madness: How Trump’s tweet subjects have evolved over time"

Leave a Comment